Best bread pan

Best Bread Pan – What Is The Best Loaf Tin For Bread?

Best bread pan
Updated on
August 23, 2022
Gareth Busby
Gareth Busby

There are a lot of factors to consider when deciding on the best bread pan for your needs. The size, type of finish, the coating applied, price, capacity, and so much more should be considered. Of course, every baker has their preferences and needs. So instead of stating which is the best bread pan, here are the bread pans that I recommend you choose from.

Caraway 1lb Loaf Pan

This loaf pan from Caraway is a fantastic choice for making bread. It is comfortable handling extremely high temperatures (550F), very durable and the non-stick liner is the best I’ve ever seen. With all of these features, the Aluminized Steel Body makes the loaf pan notably light, and great at conducting heat into your bread. The only issue I have with this Caraway loaf pan is that it is only for 1lb loaves. I wish there was a larger size available! You’ll love baking in this loaf pan and they have a great range of baking trays in their store to check out too.

Get your bread pan from Caraway here (US only)

Vogue Non-Stick Loaf Tin

An extremly durable non-stick bread tin made by Vogue, a commercial industry expert in all types of bakeware. Made from carbon steel, with a layered non-stick coating, your bread bakes quickly and releases with ease. Very durable and robust, can be dropped without denting! Makes long, thin loaves.

Dimenesions: 78(H) x 250(W) x 100(D)mm

Order this bread tin from Nesbits UK

Calphalon Nonstick Loaf Pan

This bread tin from Calphalon is one of the best pans available on Amazon. It’s made from alloy steel with a layered non-stick liner, similar to the Vogue pan. It’s reinforced rolled edges prevent the pan from warping at high temperatures. It’s dishwasher safe too!

Dimensions: 10 x 5 x 3 inches (LxWxH)

Order from Amazon

Mingcao Gold Nonstick Corrugated Pullman Pan

This is a large Pullman loaf pan design. It’s made of corrugated high carbon steel with a nonstick coating which provides a quick release and is easy to clean. The Mingcao nonstick pullman pan can be washed in the dishwasher but hand washing is recommended to maintain the coating.

BPA & PFOA free and heat-resistant up to 445℉ (230℃). The bottom vent design allows the dough to be heated more evenly. It is also the only tin I reviewed that has a 6-month warranty.

Dimensions: 8.9 x 5.1 x 5.1 inches (LxWxH)


  • When you bake a batter you’ll need to line the base with a piece of parchment!

Get your Mingcao loaf pan at Amazon

HiliStar Pullman Loaf Pan – With Lid and Accessories

A non-stick bread pan with lid, made of premium aluminium material, perfect for long-lasting use with its superior durability, resists rust and chipping. Dough capacity 1Lb (450g), and the oven temperature can reach 446F/230C. The HiliStar loaf pan is great for making classic Pullman, Pain de mie or any yeast dough loaves. Conducts heat well and comes with a plastic dough scraper, divider and a rubber sponge for cleaning. It’s a great gift idea for your friends.

Dimensions: 8.3 x 4.7 x 4.4 inches (LxWxH)


  • Small 1lb loaf size

Get yours at Amazon

The Norpro Nonstick Bread Pan

A larger bread pan suitable to bake delicious meatloaf, bread and desserts. The Norpro nonstick bread pan is made from heavy gauge steel and features corrugated sides for extra rigidity, square folded corners and tapered sides to make removal of baked goods easy. The nonstick coating ensures your baked goods will release easily when it’s time to serve them up. Hand washing is recommended.

Dimensions: 10 x 4.5 x 3 inches (LxWxH) – other sizes available


  • No lid for making Pullman-style loaves

Click to get baking with the Norpro Nonstick Bread Pan

Oak & Noble Pullman Loaf Pan With Lid

A Pullman loaf pan with lid is the perfect addition to any kitchen. In this model, its non-stick coating allows for the easy release of cakes and bread. This Oak & Noble product is made from aluminium steel, which can withstand temperatures of up to 440°F. It features a beautiful matt black finish that will complement any kitchen decor.

The non-toxic coating is BPA and PFOA free, making it safe for you and your family while adding a touch of elegance to your table setting. This versatile pan can be used to bake Pullman loaves or any type of tin bread.

Dimensions: 8.39 x 4.75 x 4.33 inches (LxWxH)

See the price on Amazon

The Lodge Loaf Pan

If you want something that you pass on to your kids or even grandkids, this Lodge loaf pan is the one! This shallow bread pan is made of cast iron which sets it apart from the other pans on the list. Cast iron is heavier than carbon steel but is so durable that it will last a lifetime, and more.

Lodge has been making cast iron pans for a long time, it’s high quality at a reasonable price. This product is unparalleled in its ability to retain heat and provide even heating. The dual handle design makes it easy to lift out of the oven, too!

Dimensions: 12 x 4.69 x 2.88 inches (LxWxH)


  • If dropped, it can easily break
  • Hard to clean as only warm water can be used

View on Amazon

Le Creuset Heritage Loaf Pan

Do you want a new item in your kitchen that you can stare at and appreciate before baking? If so, this Le Creuset pan is definitely something to consider. As we all know, Le Creuset products are the golden standards when it comes to kitchenware. So despite their heavy price tags, people continue to buy them for their quality, design, and style.

Just like with other Le Creuset products, this one is made of high-fired stoneware with glossy enamel glazing. This has a non-porous construction that resists odours, chipping, cracking, and staining. This product has a 1 1/2 qt capacity that’s safe in the oven, freezer, and microwave. Heats to 500F. One of the most expensive, but it’s the best value bread pan in this review. If your budget can stretch, this is a must-have!

Dimensions: 9 x 5 x 3 inches (LxWxH)


  • Stoneware will shatter when dropped

Get yours at Amazon!

Other notable mentions:

Amazon Basics Non-Stick Loaf Pan

Let’s start off with a pan that’s the lowest in terms of price, but one of the sturdiest on the list. This pair of loaf pans from Amazon basics are made of BPA-free carbon steel and features a non-stick coating for easy release and cleaning.

The material’s thickness is great for even heat distribution along the bottom and sides. It also has red silicone on each handle for easier transport and a more secure grip. It’s a nice little feature that can prevent accidental burns since this bread pan can handle up to 428 F in the oven.

Dimensions: 11.3 x 5.4 x 2.5 inches (LxWxH)


  • Can rust early
  • The non-stick coating is not very durable
  • Can only reach 428F in the oven

See the best price on Amazon

MONFISH Pullman Loaf Pan

The MONFISH Pullman loaf pan is a great way to add a bit of flair to your bread. It has a stylish wavy design and champagne gold colour that looks good in any kitchen! This pan is made of aluminium alloy with a non-stick coating that’s free from BPA and PFOA. This can handle up to 1lb of dough and it has three holes on the bottom. This will make sure that air can circulate when you’re going to bake with the lid that it comes with.

Dimensions: 8.5 x 4.75 x 4.375 inch (LxWxH)


  • Not recommended to bake for more than 30 minutes above 400 F
  • Small size – 450 grams of dough

See on Amazon

CHEFMADE Pullman Loaf Pan

Are you looking for a durable loaf pan that you can use every day of the week? This pan from CHEFMADE can handle anything you throw at it! Choose from a sliced or smooth texture. They are made of heavy-duty carbon steel, so you don’t have to worry about any warp or rust. It also has a food-grade silicone coating that ensures that your bread will pop right out without any too much effort. 

This pan comes in six variants, so there’s definitely one that you’re going to like. Plus, all of them have a bottom vent design that will allow for more even heating and to produce a richer taste!

Select this loaf pan on Amazon

Dimensions: Various


  • Not recommended above 428F
  • Metal is not very conductive so bread takes longer to bake
  • The quality of these tins can be poor

Original Heart Ceramic Bread Pan

Do you want a pan that you can use for special occasions? If so, this product from Original Heart is definitely something to consider. This high-quality bread pan has hand-painted, vibrant colours, and a unique design that makes the patterns look more vivid. This is made of durable stoneware, a type of premium ceramic that resists staining, odours, chipping, and cracking. It also has a non-stick and smooth glaze finish that makes it a breeze to clean.

Dimensions: 8.8 x 4.5 x 3 inches (LxWxH)


  • Only bakes to 400 F
  • Stone material could shatter if dropped

See on Amazon

Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Loaf Pan

This pan is loved by bakers everywhere for its accurate heat distribution. This is made of blended recycled and new alloy steel that can handle the high temperatures of baking. It features a unique corrugated surface design, which facilitates air circulation. This causes baked goods to be evenly baked and helps for quick release.

Dimensions: 13 x 4 x 4 inches (LxWxH)


  • The lid is flimsy and bends easily
  • Not durable enough for sustained use
  • High price

View on Amazon

If you’ve enjoyed this article and wish to treat me to a coffee, you can by following the link below – Thanks x

Buy Me A Coffee

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep up to date with the latest Articles, Recipes & Bread Baking info by joining my mailing list

Join The Weekly Bread Baker's Newsletter!

Join my weekly baking newsletter to be notified with the latest bread baking tips and trends.
Busby's Bakery

© Busby's Bakery. All rights reserved.
Designed by Joe Joubert.