Wow!!! This is very helpful. I’m very happy I found your page. Thank you for the detailed explanation.
Baker’s percentages are challenging to get your head around at first. I know many bakers struggle to understand the point of using percentages and how to use them. But once you’ve got it, you’ll realise they are pretty easy and vital to scale up or down a bread recipe. So enjoy this guide on baker’s percentages and formulas. It’s a top read!
Baker’s percentages (often referred to as “Baker’s math”) display each ingredient in a bread recipe as a percentage based on the total amount of flour. The total flour used in a recipe will always be 100%, and the ingredients are listed as percentages to produce a baker’s formula. Not restricted to bread, baker’s percentages can also be used to prepare cakes and other baked goods.
To double a recipe provided in grams, ounces, or cups is pretty simple. You just double the ingredients. But what if you wanted to change the amount of dough made by 10% to fit your bread tin better or make bigger or smaller batch sizes? This is where baker’s percentages are useful. As baker’s percentages are based on the weight of the flour required, these things are easier to work out.
Baker’s percentages also make adjusting recipes much more manageable. For example, you might want to lower the water by 3% when using a particular flour to avoid a sticky dough. It’s much easier to have a baker’s formula at hand to do this calculation than to work it out in your head!
Using a baker’s formula ensures that no matter the size of the dough, the ratio of ingredients is always the same. This means that any recipe can be scaled up or down with exact precision. Thus bakers’ percentages are absolutely vital to baking bread commercially.
To simplify the advantages of using bakers percentages in a list:
It’s best to calculate baker’s percentages by weight in grams as the metric system is much easier to calculate. It is possible to use imperial however you will have to do all your calculating in one denomination. You won’t be able to use pounds and ounces.
It is not advised to use cups and spoons to measure your ingredients. It’s not accurate, and when using a baker’s formula, you can only use one measurement. So if you don’t fancy measuring your flour with a teaspoon, you’ll need to use scales!
If you don’t have a good set of scales, this set from My-weigh are fantastic. They are durable, hard-working, accurate and affordable. I’d go for them every time!
For ultimate precession, you may like to get yourself a set of jewellery scales for measuring smaller quantities. These scales measure at 0.01 of a gram accurately and don’t cost much. Using accurate scales like these makes it easy to scale down larger recipes with precision.
Apart from scales, you’ll need a notepad and (probably) a calculator to work out the calculations. I prefer to use a spreadsheet to build a formulate my recipes. Here is a link to a blank baker’s formula spreadsheet, which you can import into Google Sheets or Excel for your own baker’s formula.
In a “professional” recipe, individual ingredients are presented as percentages in a baker’s formula. Each ingredient is calculated when making the recipe by multiplying its determined percentage by the total flour weight.
|Total flour:||570||Bakers %||Recipe|
You can see that my tin loaf recipe produces 961 grams of dough. We need 950 grams of dough to fill a 2lb loaf tin, so we make just over to make up for any dough lost in the production process.
Then if we want to make 4 bread rolls alongside our bread roll, each weighing 80 grams we can increase the size of the recipe:
1 loaf: 1 x 950 = 950
4 rolls: 4 x 80 = 320
Dough required: 950 + 320 = 1270
|Total flour:||760.00||Bakers %||Recipe|
So to calculate the weights of ingredients in this recipe manually to get the same results as the table above:
For the case of the water:
65 x 760 = 494
494 grams of water
The salt percentage for this bread dough is 2%, so:
2 x 760 = 15.2
15.2 grams of salt
For 1.6% of yeast:
1.6 x 760 = 12.2
12.2 grams of yeast
And so on..!
If we don’t know the baker’s percentage of a recipe, we could work it out with a simple calculation:
Here’s how it works in the white tin loaf example:
First, we’ll calculate the water which is 370 grams into a bakers percentage:
Total flour = 570 grams
Water = 370 grams
(370 ÷ 570) x 100 = 0.65
0.65 x 100 = 65
We now know that the baker’s percentage of water in this recipe is 65%.
This method is then repeated for all of the remaining ingredients to produce our bakers formula.
|Flour||570.00||570 ÷ 570 = 1||100.00|
|Water||370.50||370.5 ÷ 570 = 0.65||65.00|
|Yeast||9.12||9.12 ÷ 570 = 0.016||1.60|
|Salt||11.40||11.4 ÷ 570 = 0.02||2.00|
|Sugar||9.12||9.12 ÷ 570 = 0.016||1.60|
|Veg oil||2.85||2.85 ÷ 570 = 0.005||0.50|
Decimal measurements in a bread recipe can look imposing and, for many bakers, unnecessary. You are welcome to round the decimals into whole numbers when weighing your ingredients. I don’t usually do this as after rounding the decimals from the original recipe, the baker’s formula and then again when the batch size is increased, the recipe changes.
To increase our original recipe from 1 loaf to 1 loaf and 4 rolls, I increased the total flour weight. But how did I work out that I needed 760 grams of flour? We could use a spreadsheet (which I’ll come onto later) and keep tapping numbers in until the target dough weight (1270 grams) is reached, or we could use a formula to do this for us.
Knowing that 570 grams of flour produces 961 grams of dough, divide the new target dough weight by the total dough in the previous formula. Instead of 1270 grams, we’ll add 10 grams, as some dough will be lost during preparation.
Target total dough weight ÷ previous total dough weight:
1280 ÷ 961 = 1.321
Rounded, this gives us 1.32
So we now know that we need to make our original recipe 1.32 times larger. Thus the total flour of our bigger batch is:
570 x 1.32 = 752.4
Rounded to 750 grams
By setting up a spreadsheet with the values, you can speed up the time taken to work out the ingredients required. You can download my baker’s formula template and import it into google sheets or Microsoft excel. Change the total flour weight at the top of the sheet (B1), and the rest of the ingredients will self-populate.
A baker’s percentage uses the total amount of flour. That is all of the flour used in the recipe. So, if you are mixing flours in a recipe, combine their weights to make 100%. For example:
White flour @ 300 grams = 75%
Whole wheat flour @ 100 grams = 25%
75% + 25% = 100%
In a baker’s formula, the baker’s percentage should separate the ingredients used in the preferment. This means the flour from the preferment is included in the total flour weight. Let’s go through an example recipe:
For the total flour weight, add the flour in the preferment and the main dough, so we know what 100% is.
100 + 400 = 500g
500g = 100%
Therefore we can calculate the individual baker’s percentages for both instances of the flour:
100 ÷ 500 = 0.2
20% of the flour is pre-fermented
400 ÷ 500 = 0.8
80% of the flour is for the main dough
Then continue with the other ingredients using the formula:
Divide the weight of the ingredient by the weight of the flour, then multiply by 100.
The baker’s formula for this recipe looks like this:
Calculating the pre-fermented flour (PFF) percentage makes you aware of the amount of the mature preferment or sourdough starter used. This is a handy figure to know as dough with a higher PFF percentage requires shorter bulk fermentation.
To calculate the PFF percentage, divide the amount of flour that is pre-fermented by the total amount of flour used:
For the above example:
(100 ÷ 500) x 100 = PFF
0.2 x 100 = PFF
PFF is 20%
You can use a baker’s formula with sourdough recipes. As when using preferments, the water and the flour in the starter should form part of the recipes’ formula. To do this the easy way, look at the ratio that you feed your starter, ignoring the amount of old starter.
For example: If you feed your starter in a 1:1:1 ratio of starter, flour and water, the starter is deemed to be 50% flour and 50% water. If you use 150 grams of starter in your recipe, you should enter in your formula: 75 grams of flour and 75 grams of water.
If you prefer a stiffer starter and use a ratio of 1:4:3, the ratio is 4 parts flour and 3 parts water, or (100/7 * 4) 57% flour and (100/7 * 3) 43% water. For 150 grams of starter, this would be 86 grams flour and 64 grams of water. Here’s what a sourdough recipe would look like:
Sometimes a format like this is used:
|Ingredient||Bakers %||Refreshment||Main dough|
Often in professional recipes, the starter is built up, and the refreshments are included in the formula:
|Ingredient||Bakers %||1st refreshment||2nd Refreshment||Main dough|
It uses the chéf method that takes a mature starter and is “built it up”. Calculating the recipe this way provides more accuracy in terms of hydration, but as some of the started weight will evaporate, it’s not always as accurate as you think. Most home bakers prefer to just weigh their starter which is why I’ve shared this version till the end. You be you!
If you feel you need to reduce or increase the amount of water or any other ingredient in a recipe using a baker’s formula makes it easy.
To prevent a slightly sticky dough, I’ll usually reduce the percentage of water in the formula by 2%. But if you know the weight of the ingredient you want to add or remove, we can remove this accurately. Say we have our recipe:
|Total flour:||500.00||Bakers %||Recipe|
And we want to remove 15 grams of water from the main inclusion.
(15 ÷ 500) x 100 = 0.03
0.03 x 100 = 3
We need to remove 3% of the water from the original percentage:
60 – 3 = 57
Our water percentage is now 57%
57% of 500 = 285 grams
There are common relationships between the ratio of ingredients used as a basis for the majority of bread recipes. Yeast and salt typically have a percentage of 1.8-2% and water tends to be around 65% for a stiff white dough, rising to 75% for artisan or whole wheat bread.
Knowing the baker’s percentages of a new recipe helps to predict things like how quickly the dough will rise or how wet and sticky it will be. This knowledge, although not essential, enables you to understand recipes better and grow your baking skills. If you want to learn more about baker’s percentages in action, take a look at the dough hydration article. It explains how to change the water ratio in any bread recipe! Please use the comments section below to ask any questions.
Wow!!! This is very helpful. I’m very happy I found your page. Thank you for the detailed explanation.
Thanks, I’m glad you found it helpful!
Thank you so much!!! This piece is so enlightening.
You’re welcome, thank you!
Dear Mr Busby,
What joy your advice has brought to me! Thank you!
I devised my own spreadsheet style early in my bread baking experience, about 20+ years ago, so following your examples and directions is easy for me to understand and follow.
I make seven+ different flavors of bread, all whole grain. The recipe with the most different ingredients in it has 26 different things (German Black Bread). I have in my spreadsheet one column is for the water that I deduct from any ingredient and the balance of the weight goes in the solid (dry) column.
My problem is that my bread does not rise quite enough (not quite a brick). I have reduced the yeast to about 1.5%. After reading your blog, I think that my 52% hydration is my problem. I reduced the hydration from 57% to 52% because I had too many loaves flop, no more flops. I reduced the yeast and hydration at the same time. This might have been my biggest error. (hydration)
My question is: shouuld all the dry ingredients be hydrated to the same percentage as the flour?
NOTE: Low in my calculations I remove the water from the liquid ingredients so it does not get counted twice.
Thank you for your help,
Thank you, Richard!! I think I understand your question but feel free to come back to me either way!
First off, if you have 26 ingredients in a recipe then calculating the amount of water each ingredient contains is a bit overkill. Just calculate the water or milk as the hydration percentage.
If adding any water-rich items such as eggs, oil etc for the first time to a recipe, calculate the amount of water they introduce and deduct it from the water in the existing recipe.
Secondly, the percentage is for your personal recipe, if it works, who cares if you’ve not deducted the amount of water in butter? If the recipe works and scales up and down, it is perfectly usable.
Now your question “should all the dry ingredients be hydrated to the same percentage as the flour?”
Add all of the types of flour to make 100%. This could be 30% white, 60% rye and 10% spelt (or whatever).
The hydration percentage of the recipe is based on the amount of water against the total amount of flour, you don’t calculate it for each one.
The remaining dry ingredients are on top in separate percentages.
Yes, dry ingredients will contain carbs and protein (like flour), and likely contain some amount of water, but they are calculated separately. Dried fruit and nuts will soak up water -making you need to add more water to the dough. So don’t worry about perfecting the hydration percentage of individual ingredients, just be aware that you might have to increase the hydration of the dough if you add certain ingredients. Baking’s a science, but not a perfect one!
Hope that helps?
Thanks for the spreadsheet. I sent you a note regarding an addition oversight. It is a great way to start and gets you close. Next comes adjustments based on all the variables that require actual values determined empirically. That’s the fun part and once you have it, you have it, until you change something, of course.
I’ve found bread baking to be very flexible and sourdough even more so. For me, it’s mostly about hydration and my flours will tolerate a maximum of 75%. Anything higher is very unmanageable.
Hi Dave, it’s so much fun, isn’t it! Once you know the basics you can have a lot of fun by experimenting with different things! And, me too, I don’t get excited by extremely high-hydration doughs!
So glad I found your website Gareth. Learnt an awful lot just reading this post about baker’s percentages.
Thank you so much for the help you provide.
Thank you, Francois! You are very welcome.
I’m having a little trouble finding the answer to this question. In some of my bread I’m adding grated parmesan or cheddar cheese. Especially with the parmesan because it is so dry should I add that to the amount of flour and then adjust the liquid accordingly? I’m newly learning about the percentages and math is not exactly my strong point, in fact I’m really bad. So I’m trying hard to wrap my brain around the fractions and decimals. Is there a specific total percentage? Or does that matter?
Hi Joan, no worries! Don’t add the cheese to the total flour weight. The flour is the flour and only the flour.
There is no specific total percentage, it doesn’t matter. Baker’s percentages don’t add up to 100% like normal maths percentages. Instead of breaking the whole (the recipe) into parts (percentages), in a bread recipe, the total flour used is the whole (always 100%), and the other ingredients are displayed as a part of the whole (in a baker’s percentage).
You can attempt to get a really accurate formulas by adding the water content in the cheese, but it’s overkill if you’re just having a bit of fun. Just add the cheese at the end of kneading, or during bulk fermentation, it shouldn’t make much difference to the viscousness of the dough. If it does the next time you can add more or less water to compensate. Cheese is quite salty so you might want to drop the salt a little in the recipe so something like 1.4% so if using 1000grams of flour, it would be 14 grams of salt.
Also if you’re not all that confident with the maths, the easiest way to avoid it is to use 1000 grams of flour. This means to find the weight of the ingredients, you just have to add a zero to the number (or multiply by ten). For example 68% of water, would be 680 grams. Or 2% yeast, would be 20 grams of yeast. You’ll make 2 large loaves this way.
Do I add the 60g oil and 50g honey into the water percentage please.?
Hi Jeanette, not to the water percentage, it’s just for water, but you will want to decrease the amount of water in your recipe.
Reduce the water by 60 grams as oil is liquid at room temperature so makes your dough wetter. Honey is around 17% water but its sugars will absorb water in the dough so I wouldn’t bother including the (50/100 *17) 8.5 grams of water to the overall hydration of your dough, or deducting it from the amount of water. Just leave water percentage as the main liquid (usually water but possibly milk). This might be explained better here: https://www.busbysbakery.com/dough-hydration/
Hi, I’m Gareth Busby, a baking coach, head baker and bread-baking fanatic! My aim is to use science, techniques and 15 years of baking experience to help you become a better baker.
Suite 2646 Unit 3A,
34-35 Hatton Garden,